Public Records Request #4 – Reilly v. North Broward Hospital District, et al.,

Sent: Wednesday, September 16, 2015 9:02 AM
Subject: Public Records Request #4 – Reilly v. North Broward Hospital District, et al., Case No. 10-60590 (S.D. Fla.)

September 16, 2015

Lynn Barrett, General Counsel
North Broward Hospital District
Broward Health Spectrum Office
1700 NW 49 Street,
Fort Lauderdale, Florida

Re: Public Records Request #4 – Reilly v. North Broward Hospital District, et al., Case No. 10-60590 (S.D. Fla.)

Dear Ms. Barrett,

This letter is a public records request pursuant to the Public Records Act, Florida Statutes, Section 119 to allow the inspection and copying of public records. This request is also made pursuant to Art. 1, s. 24(a), Fla. Const. which establishes a constitutional right of access to any public record made or received in connection with the official business of any public body, officer, or employee of the state, or persons acting on their behalf.

YOU ARE CAUTIONED THAT THE FAILURE OF THE REQUESTEE TO FULLY COMPLY MAY RESULT, INTER ALIA, IN THE INSTITUTION OF LITIGATION, THE REQUEST FOR APPOINTMENT BY THE COURT OF AN INDEPENDENT REVIEW AND AN AWARD OF ATTORNEY’S FEES AND COSTS TO REQUESTOR’S LEGAL COUNSEL.

Please provide me electronic copies of the following records to Dan@BrwdHealth.com which as a result of the settlement of United States ex rel. Reilly v. North Broward Hospital District, et al., Case No. 10-60590 (S.D. Fla.) have now become public.

  1. The recorded and transcribed minutes of all shade meetings held in this matter by the Board of Broward Health.

As a corollary to the above matter and consistent with the public’s right to know and the public interest in the appropriate expenditure of their tax funds, please provide me electronic copies of the following records to Dan@BrwdHeath.com or alternatively, please let me know when the following records are available for my inspection.

  1. Copies of all invoices from Broward Health’s Fair Market Analysis contractor for 2014 through the date of this production.
  2. Copies of all Fair Market Value Analysis provided by Broward Health’s independent consultant to Broward Health for 2014 through the date of this production.

In previous public records requests, I have requested copies of physician service, employment and medical directorship contracts that have, in part, been produced with excluded scope of services and compensation sections.  These fundamental and basic elements of these contracts have been excluded by Broward Health asserting privilege for confidential and trade secret information.

I would argue that fair market value, by definition, cannot be a confidential or a trade secret and that the disclosure of the financial arrangements by contract for physician professional services by Broward Health is both necessary and in the public interest in light of the recent settlement.  It is noteworthy that this information is considered a public record by the Memorial system, as well as other public hospitals in Florida.  Therefore, please provide me electronic copies of the following records to Dan@BrwdHeath.com or alternatively, please let me know when the following records are available for my inspection.

  1. Complete copies of all executed contracts between Broward Health and physicians for professional or any other services for which a Fair Market Analysis was utilized for 2014 through the date of this production.

If you have a requested public record but claim a privilege which protects you from providing it pursuant to this public records request, A LOG SHOULD BE PROVIDED IDENTIFYING THE SPECIFIC DOCUMENT/ COMMUNICATION BEING WITHHELD, AND THE LEGAL BASIS FOR THE CLAIMED PRIVILEGE.

Please note that section 119.07(2)(a) of the Public Records Law provides that a person who has custody of a public record and who asserts that an exemption applies to a particular pubic record or part of such record shall delete or excise from the record only that portion of the record with respect to which an exemption has been asserted and validly applies, and such person shall produce the remainder of such record for inspection and examination.  This section further provides that if the person who has custody of a public record contends that the record or part of it is exempt from inspection, he shall state the basis of the exemption which he contends is applicable to the record, including the statutory citation to an exemption created or afforded by statute, and, if requested by the person seeking the right under this subsection to inspect, examine, or copy the record, he shall state in writing and with particularity the reasons for his conclusion that the record is exempt.

It is hereby requested that you do state in writing both the statutory citation to any exemption which you claim applicable to any requested record and the specific reasons for a conclusion that the requested record is exempt.

Also, please note that section 119.07(2)(C) prohibits the destruction of any of the requested records, including any which you claim are exempt, for a period of 30 days after the date on which you receive this written request.  If a civil action is instituted to enforce the Public Records Law with respect to the requested records within the 30-day period, you may not dispose of the records except by court order after notice to all affected parties.

As a matter of Florida law, unless the nature or volume of public records to be inspected or copied requires “extensive” use of information technology resources or “extensive” clerical or supervisory assistance, the special service charge is not authorized. If authorized due to the nature or volume of a request, the special service charge should not be routinely imposed, but should reflect the information technology resources or labor costs actually incurred by the agency. AGO 90-07. And see, AGOs 92-38, 86-69 and 84-81.  Moreover, the statute mandates that the special service charge be “reasonable.” See, Carden v. Chief of Police, 696 So. 2d 772, 773 (Fla. 2d DCA 1996), stating that an “excessive charge” under s. 119.07(1)(b), F.S., “could well serve to inhibit the pursuit of rights conferred by the Public Records Act.”

After inspection, I agree that I will compensate you for the actual cost of duplication of any of the records that I have requested.  If the nature or volume of the public records requested is such to require extensive use of information technology resources and/or extensive clerical and/or supervisory assistance by personnel of your office, I agree that I will compensate you for those costs that are reasonable as well, subject to the terms enumerated herein.  Before incurring any charges, please contact me and advise me of the actual cost basis of duplication and/or any necessary and reasonable staff research time.

I would appreciate confirmation that you have received this request and an estimated date of when I might receive and/or inspect the public records. Thank you in advance for your prompt consideration of my request. Please feel free to contact me if you have any questions.

Thank you for your kind attention to my request.

About Dan Lewis

Dan Lewis is a Systems Architect, Crisis Management; Political Micro-Targeting Analytics & Message Development Consulting; JNAC Communications & Management Services, LLC. CEO/Founder; Past Service: • Miramar City Commissioner, • Broward County Growth Management advisory committee, Chair, • Broward County Management & Efficiency Study Committee, Chair, • Broward County Charter Review Committee, Chair; Broward County Growth Management Advisory Committee, Chair, • Member of 7 school Sit Teams, president of 5; • BCSB Consultant’s Review Committee, • BCSB Audit Committee, • BCSB Diversity Committee • Broward County Health Facilities Authority
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Public Records Request #4 – Reilly v. North Broward Hospital District, et al.,

  1. Rose says:

    I am curious to know if you got a reply to your request..really if you were given the records which the public has legal right to have access to. Why is the Justice Dept accepting tax payer money from Health Broward instead of sourcing the punitive damages from their own personal pockets? How was justice served? What ever happened to the doctors who were subpoenaed? Did their salaries get revised? By how much? We should know since we pay their salaries with our tax dollars! What kind of job did the FBI do for this white collar criminals to – as their CEO stated – “move on” and even have the nerve to say these were just “allegations”? If they were just “allegations” why did they agree to pay almost $70M? How about the board? Were they personally liable for breaking the law? Has a new board been appointed after this fiasco? And if the FBI is truly doing their due diligence, how can they trust a process where our own governor Rick Scott, was the CEO of Columbia/HCA – the one company which committed the largest Medicare fraud in the history of the United States? Why isn’t this making national news? It is unbelievable that this is happening in the US. It feels we are in Nicaragua or Botsuana. Unreal.

  2. Worried about Broward Health says:

    When will the citizens of Broward County and the employees of Broward Health take action… Nabil El Sanadi is the CEO of the 10th largest health care organization (BH) in the nation yet prior to this he never managed a business with more than 5 employees!!! He was inept at leading the emergency departments so why would anyone think it would be a good idea to make him CEO? What an enigma!! The people who are unfortunate enough to work beside him now must be petrified!!! Broward Health is in serious trouble with El Sanadi in charge.

  3. Worried about Broward Health says:

    When will the citizens of Broward County and the employees of Broward Health take action? Nabil El Sanadi is the CEO of the 10th largest health care organization (BH) in the nation yet prior to this he never managed a business with more than 5 employees!!! He was inept at leading the emergency departments so why would anyone think it would be a good idea to make him CEO? What an enigma!! The people who are unfortunate enough to work beside him now must be petrified!!! Broward Health is in serious trouble with El Sanadi in charge. Start writing your elected officials.

Leave a Reply